Both use far less electricity than a full oven. Air fryers crisp faster; toaster ovens hold more food, toast better and handle baking and broiling.
🇺🇸 US · Last updated November 12, 2026
We may earn a commission from links. It never changes the scores.
The air fryer wins for one or two people who want crispy food fast. A toaster oven is better for families and for toast, baking and broiling.
Strong fans in a small basket crisp food fast.
Many toaster ovens fit a small chicken or a 9x13 dish.
Air fryers need little or no preheating.
Shorter cook times usually mean less energy overall.
Toaster ovens toast, bake and broil up to about 450°F.
Basket air fryers have a smaller footprint.
Pick an air fryer for quick, crispy meals for 1–2 people.
Pick a toaster oven for families, toast, baking and bigger dishes.
ⓘ Results depend on the model and size. An air-fry toaster oven is a good middle ground.